Tuesday, November 17, 2026

The Joy of Six 1608

Nicola Slawson and Jane Clinton talk to young people the impact of an endless cycle of job applications and rejections: "I would like to not be on benefits. I would like to have a proper entry-level job in what I studied, but I haven’t been able to get anything. I’m trying."

"John Healey’s underwhelming budget could only find an extra £1.5bn for social and 'affordable' housing – which, apart from anything else, once again underlined the fact that the latter term is often all but meaningless." John Harris asks if Andy Burnham’s plan for a housing revolution is anything more than a pipedream.

"The heart of the problem is simple. No other lender could do what successive governments have done to Plan 2 borrowers. Graduates signed up at 18, often on the strength of promotional material that compared repayments to a phone contract. Since then, the terms have been changed again and again, nearly always to the borrower’s cost." Tom Gordon, Lib Dem MP for Harrogate and Knaresborough, says it's time to fix student loans.

Philip Stephens skewers Michael Gove and his "insouciant mendacity".

"Through tense encounters with the police, schools and social welfare services, the film tackles cultural and moral divides in all their forms. It explores discipline and abuse, religious dogma, gender roles, sexuality and the clash between progressive ideals and conservative faith." Caroline Oliver watches Fjord (2026).

JacquiWine recommends 10 haunting, atmospheric novellas.

Monday, November 16, 2026

John Pardoe died yesterday at the age of 92


Ben Maguire, the current Liberal Democrat MP for John Pardoe's old constituency of North Cornwall, sent this message earlier today.

John Pardoe was MP for North Cornwall from 1966 to 1979, and was the Liberal Party's Treasury spokesperson from 1970, serving under both Jeremy Thorpe and David Steel. He lost to Steel in the 1976 Liberal Party leadership election.

He was one of my early political heroes and I am very sorry to hear of his death.

The many incarnations of Shoreditch High Street station

Jago Hazzard takes us through the varied railway history of this now-fashionable quarter of London. One thing I hadn't grasped before was that Broad Street was there before Liverpool Street.

"Broad Street station?" I hear you ask.

You can support Jago Hazzard's videos via his Patreon page.

Labour and the NEETs: Nothing has changed in 30 years

Embed from Getty Images

In a letter to the Guardian on 15 September 1997, Jonathan Calder wrote: "Labour is effectively recasting unemployment as a form of individual delinquency."

That letter can no longer be found on the Guardian website, but its central point is preserved for ever in this quotation from The Age of Insecurity by Larry Elliott and Dan Atkinson (published in 1998).

What is depressing is that nothing has changed in the three decades since I wrote that letter. The current debate over NEETs is predicated on the belief that is only young people stirred themselves they would find jobs. Hence the emphasis on the question of whether welfare benefits are too generous.

One exception to this approach can be found in an article from today's Guardian by Richard Partington:

Unemployment among the under-25s has risen at the fastest rate since the 2008 financial crisis to reach its highest level relative to the total for all ages since the early 1990s. Young people now make up about 40 per cent of all unemployment.

All of this compounds a drop in entry-level jobs over the past two decades. The Saturday job died long ago, while to make matters worse, those positions at the start of the career ladder are most at risk of automation or replacement by AI.

Perhaps unsurprisingly, the places in Britain with the fewest job vacancies have the highest Neet rates. Highlighting stark regional divisions, young jobseekers in Rotherham face a sixfold gap in opportunity relative to their peers in the Cotswolds.

The preferred fixes called for by employers are tax cuts, looser regulations, and holding back rises in the youth minimum wage. But while policy costs are unquestionably a factor to consider, and the state could do more to help young people get ready for work, the problems go much deeper.

Labour and Liberal politicians have lost any notion that it is possible for them to intervene beneficently at a macroeconomic level. All that remain are interventions to make the young keener to work or more fitted to the workplace – and this at a time when we are told we should be celebrating the success of English schools at least in the PISA tables.

It's enough to make you nostalgia for the Thatcher government, which paid an enterprise allowance to young people who wanted to start their own business. This helped many musicians and other artists with very unThatcherite politics to pursue their dreams.

The life and paintings of Thomas Cooper Gotch

I came across the work of the painter Thomas Cooper Gotch when I visited the Alfred East Gallery in Kettering the other day.

The Penlee House Gallery and Museum in Penzance has a useful summary of his career:

Born in Kettering in Northamptonshire, 'Tom' Gotch left school to work at his family's boot & shoe business before embarking on his artistic career. He began his formal art training at Heatherley’s Art School in 1876, aged 21, and entered the Slade in 1879 where he became a close friend of the painter Henry Scott Tuke.

At the instigation of his future wife, fellow artist and Slade student, Caroline Burland Yates, Gotch and Tuke first visited Newlyn in 1879. Tom and Carrie returned to marry at St Peter's Church in Newlyn in 1881, but then both resumed their studies in Paris at Julian’s and Lauren’s Academies and they did not become resident in Newlyn until 1887.

At first Gotch adopted the Newlyners' 'rural realist' style, but in 1891 they wintered in Florence which marked a change in the style of his work to incorporate a "joyous sense of colour". Many of his later works are influenced by the resurgence of interest in mediaevalism and resemble Pre-Raphaelite paintings. Of these, probably his most famous work is Alleluia 1896 (Tate Britain).

Gotch frequently used local models in his works, including his own daughter, Phyllis, who was famed in later life for her leading role in stopping the Newlyn 'slum clearances'. Gotch also modelled for his artist friends, and is the model for King Arthur in Elizabeth Forbes’ illustrated book King Arthur’s Wood.

There is a biography of Gotch, The Golden Dream: A biography of Thomas Cooper Gotch, by Pamela Lomax.

And you can see a generous selection of his work in the video above.

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Confessions of a London River Hunter by John Rogers

My favourite videos by John Rogers, whose work features here regularly, are the ones where he goes in search of one of London's lost rivers. Not just well-recorded tributaries of the Thames like the Tyburn and Fleet, but little-known rivers out in the suburbs too.

So it's good news that John has a new book out: Confessions of a London River Hunter.

The blurb says:
London is a city of rivers: there are said to be over 350 rivers and streams in Greater London. Most have slipped from the consciousness of the city yet they trickle on through parks and open spaces, behind houses and under roads, winding their stories through the fabric of London and whispering their legends. 
From the western marshes of the Yeading Brook to the lost river of Leytonstone, the channels of the moon goddess, a haunted stream, long buried City tributaries and a brook rescued from the thickets, John Rogers walked some of London’s most storied watercourses that rarely get acknowledged, and attempts to find a way to hear their tales.
One thing I have learnt from his river videos is that people rarely built house over old watercourses. So if you are hunting a river and come across an electricity substation on one side of the road and garages on the other, there's a good chance that this is where that river crossed.

Market Harborough doesn't have a lost river, but it does have a diverted one. Before the railways arrived,  the River Jordan used to flow through the fields by Gores Lane and join the Welland somewhere there. I once came across an old newspaper story from between the wars that said you could still see the old course of the Jordan in the fields when heavy rain flooded them.

It's been partly filled by modern buildings now, but if you look at the North side of Rockingham Road after the railway bridge you can see that a large gap was left before the first house was built. That gap must surely be where the Jordan used to flow.

The Joy of Six 1607

"We spend about 50 per cent of our clinical budget in the NHS on inpatient care. That’s what it’s called, inpatient care. But in many respects, it’s akin to incarceration. Everybody in England is locked up, whether they’re voluntary patients or detained under the Mental Health Act. That in itself is really shocking, it seems to me. The use of restraints remains endemic in the system, and you’re more likely, if you’re Black, to experience this sort of coercion." Norman Lamb talks to Mad in the UK about his book Be More Human: Why Mental Health Care is Broken – and What We Can Do to Fix It.

Emily Chiang on how groomers operate and why victims become trapped.

Chris Grey explains why Brexit won't go away: "It doesn’t matter whether, as some Brexit supporters often say, 'we managed perfectly well before' even if that were true (which it isn't). It doesn't even matter whether one thinks the EU is 'a good thing' or not. And it certainly doesn't matter that the EU is imperfect and has many problems. It is simply a fact that the EU exists and, as such, it affects a huge amount of what happens in the UK irrespective of whether the UK is a member or not."

"When the singer Charlotte Church was 15, a website ran a countdown to her 16th birthday, when she would reach the age of consent – which was reported by the Sun. The Radio 1 presenter Chris Moyles, then 28, spoke on air about wanting to take Church’s virginity when she turned 16." Nadia Khomami says 2000s pop culture was profoundly, cheerfully horrible to women.

Michael Walker remembers Gram Parsons, who died in 1973 at the age of 26 at a Joshua Tree, California, motel.

"He had just received a severe flogging at school and ran away rather than returning ... that afternoon. He stopped to listen to organ music coming from a church and walked through a nearby archway, finding himself in an unfamiliar small town. It was entirely empty, but he entered one house, ascended the stairs and looked out at the view – an unfamiliar river valley. Years later, as a soldier in the British army in 1917, he found himself among deserted villages in the valley of the Somme that had been abandoned by the retreating Germans. Visiting one of them, he was shocked to recognise it as the village he had visited as a seven-year-old boy ... He entered a house and climbed the stairs to look at the view, and sure enough it was what he had seen all those years ago – the Somme valley laid out beneath him." Francis Young discovers a book from 1978 on timeslips.

Jethro Tull: And The Mouse Police Never Sleeps

Here's Jethro Tull miming to a track from their 1978 album Heavy Horses, the middle one of their folk-rock trilogy from this era.

I liked Songs from the Wood and Heavy Horses immensely when I was 18, and it was when I started exploring Tull's back catalogue that I discovered British R&B.

And The Mouse Police Never Sleeps may be the best pop or rock song about cats there is. I still feel, however, that the mouse police should not be a description of cats but an organisation of mice that shares intelligence about cats' movements and helps other mice escape from them, as well as maintaining law and order in the mouse community.

Saturday, November 14, 2026

Alexei Sayle dandled the infant Jacob Rees-Mogg on his knee

Can it be true? It can.

Back in 2016 Alexei Sayle gave an interview to the Waterstones website as part of the publicity campaign for Thatcher Stole My Trousers, the second volume of his memoirs.

In the course of it he recalled:

When I was a student at Chelsea School of Art in the early 70s, feeling very lost and out of my depth, the only lecturer who was really nice to me was a woman called Anne Rees-Mogg who taught Film Studies. 

Anne involved herself to a greater degree than the rest of the staff with her students, particularly the boys whom she collected around her so that we formed an odd little troop, wandering around accompanied by the ticking sound of our clockwork cameras. 

She was happy to help her students and would drive us anywhere we wanted to go in her brown Ford Escort estate. The only problem was that she never changed out of third gear, so we travelled everywhere at thirty miles-an-hour in a cloud of smoke and disintegrating clutch.

Hers was the only home of a Chelsea staff member I was ever invited to. Anne’s brother was William Rees Mogg – the father of Jacob – and, though childless herself, I recall that she was obsessed with her nephew the infant Jacob; he even looks a lot like her. 

My memory is that Anne was looking after the young Jacob when I called in on her uninvited (I did a lot of that) one Saturday afternoon. She passed the baby to me, thinking it would be a treat for me to dandle him on my knee. I am also (intentionally) childless and did not really know what to make of the solemn child on my lap, but I professed great delight at his every move to please the doting Anne.

Anne died in 1984, the first friend that I lost, and I think of her every time I see Jacob on TV. It is odd to be reminded of someone that you loved by somebody whose politics you so dislike.

Faces and Places exhibition at the Alfred East Gallery, Kettering


Yesterday, after breakfast at Kafe Blok across the road, I visited the reopened Alfred East Gallery in Kettering.

The Faces and Places exhibition put on for its reopening fills both rooms of the gallery. One is largely devoted to the work of Alfred East and the other to that of another Kettering artist, Thomas Cooper Gotch.

East had a high reputation at his death in 1913, but is not well known today. This video clip from the BBC's Antiques Roadshow gives a fair summation of his strengths and weaknesses as a painter.

Gotch is more interesting to the modern eye, particularly his Death the Bride, which is nearest the camera in the photograph below. The black veil and poppies make it dark and portentous, yet the young woman looks a minx and is giving the onlooker a casual wave.

Kettering did a great thing in building its own art gallery. East gave dozens of his paintings to the town on condition that it was there to display them.

Its collection now reaches far beyond East and Gotch, and I shall be back to see what follows Faces and Places.

Friday, November 13, 2026

A 14-year-old Mick Jagger demonstrates rock climbing on television


How come Mick Jagger can still strut his stuff on stage even though he's in his eighties?

Part of it is his fitness regime, a "combination of gym sessions, dancing, running, swimming, cycling, kickboxing, yoga and Pilates". 

And part must be an active youth. Mick's father, Basil Joe Jagger, was a PE teacher and gymnast who helped popularise basketball in Britain.

You can see a 14-year-old Mick and his dad in the video above, which is taken from a 1959 edition of the ATV children's programme Seeing Sport.

The Joy of Six 1606

"The world’s biggest climate conference kicked off today in Antalya, Turkey, a country known for growing political repression. Under an unusual compromise, Turkey is hosting, but Australia’s government will preside over negotiations among more than 190 nations seeking to address the climate crisis. And for the third year in a row, one problem underscores all the others: Why can’t anyone say 'fossil fuels'?" Rachel Santarsiero reports from COP31.

Mic Wright takes aim at Jonathan Ross: "None of this is to say that Ross is responsible for Brand’s crimes or knew about the truth behind his performance nor that he carries particular blame for the alleged behaviour of David Walliams. It’s just that spending time going through the careers of both Walliams and Brand shows Ross appearing at key moments like a Forrest Gump for creeps, often making jokes that refer explicitly to that very creepiness."

Vincent Charles and Tatiana Gherman say the supermarket fridge hack has exposed the cracks in tech vision of an 'internet of things'.

"These spaces are thought to improve child mental health by encouraging healthy behaviour. For example, they encourage physical activity, socialising and imaginative and adventurous play. Research suggests that being in natural spaces can have restorative and stress-reducing effects for both children and adults." Mark Ferguson finds that going to the park once a week or more has a measurable impact on a child’s mental health.

Ed Douglas celebrates the latest step in the 'daylighting' of a Sheffield river: "It is the first view of the River Sheaf at this spot since the late 1860s, when it was culverted and plunged into darkness for the construction of Sheffield station, right where another stream, the Porter Brook, flows into it. Now, like some Roman mosaic or Anglo-Saxon hoard, a fragment of this treasure has been exposed, with the opening of a lightwell, protected by a steel grille, that allows rail passengers to look down on the lost river that gave their city its name."

Bobby Henrey's performance in The Fallen Idol (1948) is acclaimed, but the books say he was terrible in his only other film. Shadowplay watches The Wonder Kid (1951) and finds more to enjoy than you would expect.

Summer drought means no jump meetings at Ludlow this winter

Embed from Getty Images

In a development that will bring the reality of the climate crisis home to a certain kind of Tory, Ludlow race course has been forced to cancel its entire winter National Hunt programme because of last summer's drought.

BBC News explains:

The issue has been trying to replace dead grass and encourage new growth on approximately 25 per cent of the quick-draining, gravel-based track.

But, although the rain did return in September, there has not been enough to help stimulate sufficient grass growth as the days have shortened.

The course's almost unique capacity to drain well enough to stay in raceworthy condition throughout many a wet autumn and winter has proved on this occasion to be its undoing.

A total of 14 race meeting will now be transferred from Ludlow to other courses.

Thursday, November 12, 2026

Accounting for the abandoned Winwick Hospital branch

Here's a large chunk of one of the Sighcology columns I write for the Journal of Critical Psychology, Counselling and Psychotherapy.

Why did these hospitals have those gigantic water-towers and chimneys? Dr Claire Hilton, the historian in residence at the Royal College of Psychiatrists, once discussed the question on the college’s website.

One reason was the institutions’ remoteness, whether this was dictated by a Victorian faith in the restorative powers of country air or a more 20th-century desire to hide the unfit away. It meant they often lacked mains water – many villages were not connected until after the second world war – so pumping water up to a storage tank at the top of a tower was the only way to ensure a sufficient and reliable supply. And the size of the asylums, which might have over 2,000 residents, dictated that those tanks would be huge.

Hilton quotes an 1894 book on the management of asylums as recommending the water tower be at least 20 feet higher than the highest part of the rest of the building and the tank capacious enough to hold at least 48 hours' supply. And in those days, the pumping this entailed meant the hospital needed a powerful steam engine – hence the chimneys.

The water supply had another use: fighting the fires to which their conditions made these buildings vulnerable. Many asylums, says Hilton, formed their own fire brigades of staff and patients.

******

If you had an engine in steam every day, then you got through a lot of coal. And that coal had to be brought to the hospital, often over inadequate rural roads. The solution many hospital boards and councils came up with was a railway: sometimes a whole complex of lines.

In 1896 the London County Council purchased the Horton Estate in Surrey with the intention of building a cluster of mental hospitals and other institutions there. A railway system, linked with the main line, was built to carry materials for the construction of the hospitals and then carry the coal and other goods they required for day-to-day operation. The cluster, naturally, had its own power station.

In the 1920s the volume of coal and coke delivered to the power station, and to glasshouses at one of the hospitals, reached a peak of 15,000 tonnes per year.

This railway system was little used during the second world war, when some of the hospitals were given over to wounded and recuperating soldiers, and it was scrapped not long after hostilities ceased. But before it closed, enthusiasts in sports jackets and flannels came to photograph the operations for railway magazines. It is said you can still find traces of the lines among the housing estates, private roads and golf courses that now occupy the Horton Estate.

All this explains why a mental hospital needed its own branch line off the West Coast Main Line. The video above shows RWH Trains exploring what remains of it today.

Winwick Hospital opened in 1902, which neatly illustrates a point made in the Sighcology I have just sent off: the practices we condemn as "Victorian" often belong in reality to the 20th century.

A mermaid saved from drowning plus the mole men of New York

Embed from Getty Images

Some more gleanings from the December issue of Fortean Times.

First, there is the story from Mainz in Germany about the man who called the police when he saw someone in difficulty in the Rheine. When the cops arrived, they discovered it was a woman with a fish's tail – not an actual mermaid, but someone enjoying the now popular sport of mermaid swimming. She told them she had intended to keep close to the bank but had been carried out by the current.

The same item also covers a story from Germany's fake newspaper Der Postillon about the low water levels stranding "hundreds of dead or dying" mermaids on the newly exposed gravel flats along the Rhine. There's even a photo.

Weialala leia
Wallala leialala

you might say.

The magazine also casts more light on the story about the mole men of New York I blogged about a while ago.

It turns out that the people seen lifting manhole covers and climbing in and out of the sewers weren't terrorists or anything sinister like that. They were looking for lost valuables down there.

FT compares them to the 'toshers' who once scavenged London's sewers:

a tight-knit community with its own skills and folklore, made a precarious living by entering the city sewers to seek valuables until their activities were made illegal and easy access to the tunnels was closed off by the construction of Bazalgette's sewer along the Thames Embankment.

Entering the sewers in New York or anywhere is dangerous, of course, and not just for those taking part. In Manhattan earlier this year, a woman stepped out of a car and fell to her death down an uncovered manhole. It is thought trespassers may have been responsible for leaving it like that.

Write a guest post for Liberal England


I love publishing guest posts here on Liberal England. Have you thought of writing one yourself?

It could be on Liberal politics or culture or… anything really.  Why not an article about a local campaign or quirky piece of history? Perhaps you have a book to promote?

Please drop me an email if you'd like to discuss your idea first. I'd hate you to spend time on a piece I really wouldn’t want to publish.

Here are the last 10 guest posts on this blog:

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Pippa Heylings woos disaffected Greens as COP31 opens

Embed from Getty Images

"You have a home with us," Pippa Heylings has said in an open letter to Green members who feel environmental issues have slipped down the party's agenda in recent month reports, Politics.co.uk.

Heylings, who is the Liberal Democrat spokesperson on energy security and net zero as well as being MP for South Cambridgeshire, published her letter as COP31. the United Nations' annual climate change conference, got underway in Antalya, Turkey.

In it, says the website, Heylings (seen nearest the camera in the photo above) sets out five environmental commitments championed by the Lib Dems:

She cites the Sunshine Bill, which would require developers to fit new-builds with solar panels and heat pumps. The bill was brought forward by Max Wilkinson, the Liberal Democrat home affairs spokesperson, in October 2024. 

The government declined to support the bill at the time, but Wilkinson’s campaign was ultimately successful. In June 2025, the government announced it would incorporate the mandate for solar panels on the "vast majority" of new build homes into the upcoming Future Homes Standard. Ed Miliband, the energy secretary, described the move as "just common sense".

On water, Heylings said the Liberal Democrats were fighting for a regulator with "real teeth" to replace Ofwat, with water companies run "for the public benefit rather than shareholders".

The letter also vows a £1 billion uplift to funding for nature-friendly farming schemes, with support for regenerative farming and a national "call to store" programme to help farms withstand drought and flood. Heylings added that the party would seek a cross-party national plan for heatwaves, drought and flooding.

This is an impressive environmental programme. Greens who despair of Polanskio-Corbynism would probably be more at home in the Lib Dems than the Labour Party. And they would be good for the Lib Dems too.

The Joy of Six 1605

"The public’s disgust with Trump is now inextricably bound up with disgust for that other cult – the smug-maxxing techno-narcissists who think we all want to live in the world they’re designing." Tina Brown looks at America after the midterms.

Sol Gamsu finds that Britain's schools are segregated by social class – in London in particular: "For post-16 education, London’s state schools and colleges are very unequal. In affluent western boroughs such as Richmond upon Thames or Kingston, working-class students are heavily concentrated in further education colleges, with a larger number of more middle-class state schools."

Lindsey Blumell says the media ultimately exposed Russell Brand, but his fame and celebrity added to victims' trauma: "The trial is an example of the role media can play in uplifting the career of powerful people like Brand. This is both through platforming celebrities in 'puff' articles and TV segments, as well as in their failure to act on reports of unprofessional and illegal behaviour."

"There is a note of tragedy in all of this, I think. In the days before sinking to the level of ugly and disreputable grouches such as Brendan O’Neill and Richard Littlejohn, Pearson was first a reliably clever TV reviewer for the Independent, then a bona fide literary sensation." Ian Winwood accounts for the hurtle to the right of my old classmate Allison Pearson.

"Made at Ealing Studios, Dead of Night ingeniously weaves together the separate visions of four directors. And it is the hand of Alberto Cavalcanti that gives his short tale of a ventriloquist going mad – or being driven to madness by supernatural means – its peculiar and lasting power." Self-Styled Siren on the Brazilian who also directed Went the Day Well?

Giles Wilcock on the mystery of the Black cricketer who played for the MCC in 1902.

Small Faces: Itchycoo Park


Once, long before you were born, I played this over and over again on the jukebox of The Bird in Hand, Henstridge. 

The pub also had a bar billiards table, so it was a good evening.

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Michael Moorcock and Iain Sinclair in conversation


From The Morecambe Fringe Festival Podcast:

In this episode writer and filmmaker Iain Sinclair catches up with Sci-Fi author and Hawkwind collaborator Michael Moorcock in an exclusive Morecambe Fringe Podcast interview.

Click on the image above to listen to it.

The letter on Russell Brand that the Guardian declined to publish


Yesterday's Joy of Six included a post by Lucy Siegle about the Guardian's long and close involvement with Russell Brand in . In it Siegle, a former Guardian journalist herself, referred to a letter she had written to the newspaper.

As she expected, that letter has not been published, so she has included it in a new post on her blog:

The Guardian must examine its own role in enabling Russell Brand

Your editorial on Russell Brand’s conviction (The Guardian view on Russell Brand: his conviction sends a powerful message, Friday 6th November) rightly challenges the media culture that enabled his behaviour. But why does the Guardian apply so little scrutiny to its own role in the creating and sustaining of Russell Brand’s media power?

Brand is described, almost in passing, as someone who was ‘also once a Guardian sports columnist’. Yet the Guardian’s relationship with him extended considerably further. It serialised his autobiography My Booky Wook, gave him extensive editorial exposure and, as late as 2014, staged a Guardian Live event broadcast to cinemas across the country. He is not simply a former sports columnist. He is a celebrity whose profile, cultural authority and commercial appeal the Guardian helped cultivate. It is a matter of public record how much Brand cultivated and received The Guardian’s patronage. Apparently this ran both ways. In his ‘Farewell Readers’ sign off in 2015, former editor Alan Rusbridger included Russell Brand at Guardian conference as one of the highlights of his tenure. (By the way, there is a photograph commemorating this historic moment on your website).

I founded and ran the annual Observer Ethical Awards, 2004-2014, when the Observer was owned by Guardian News and Media. On several occasions through the Guardian’s commercial department it was suggested that I should add Brand as a celebrity judge. I refused because I had heard troubling accounts of his behaviour towards women. I can’t say who knew what, but the concerns that were circulating were certainly sufficient for me to decide that he should not be anywhere near my event.

Your editorial notes that the BBC and Channel 4 conducted internal reviews and issued apologies following the revelations about Brand. What examination has the Guardian undertaken of its own decisions to commission, promote and publicly associate itself with him?

It is easy to condemn the culture of male entitlement once a celebrity has been convicted. The harder task is to examine the institutional decisions that sustained his power when he was still commercially valuable. The Guardian should be prepared to apply that scrutiny to itself. Unhappily, this is not the first time that I have had to make this point to you.

Lucy Siegle
Former Guardian News and Media staffer, and former Observer columnist.

Both blog posts are worth reading in full.

Charlotte Cane, Malcolm Saville and the floods of 1947

Charlotte Cane, the Liberal Democrat MP for Ely and East Cambridgeshire, has been elected chair of the all-party parliamentary group for sustainable flood and drought management, reports the Ely Standard.

And it's no wonder that she takes an interest in such matters. As Cambridgeshire Live once described, the freezing winter of 1946/7 was followed by something worse:

Swollen by torrential rain, the onset of a rapid thaw, and unusually high spring tides, all the major rivers burst their banks, inundating farmland, roads and homes.

A vast area of land was swamped, half of it prime arable land desperately needed to supply a population only just freed from the grip of war. Sowings of winter wheat and vast quantities of potatoes were submerged.

In the low lying areas close to the Great Ouse, Welland and Nene, the floodwater tore huge breaches in the river banks, and hundreds of families were made homeless. The sheer force of the water smashed fences, knocked down doors and destroyed walls, even those made of brick.

Thousands of pigs, cattle, sheep and poultry were swept away too – but miraculously no human lives were lost.

Local people were joined by Army men – and prisoners-of-war – in battling to keep the water at bay, but could do little to prevent further damage. Many of the embankments had been established way back in the 17th century by the Dutch engineer Cornelius Vermuyden as part of the vast fenland drainage project.

Perhaps because of this miraculous preservation of human life, I sense that the floods of 1947 have faded from popular memory in the way that the East Coast floods of 1953 haven't.

But those of us who grew up on Malcolm Saville will know all about them, because his book The Luck of Sallowby was set in the Isle of Ely against the background of these floods.

So here is Saville in mid-season form:

Now they were close against the wall they saw it was only a few inches higher than the rising water which stretched before them in a turbulent brown lake, whipped into waves by the gale. And these waves beat against the wall ceaselessly and the spray from them blew over the top and drenched the bags and settled in pools on the tarpaulins and made the blue clay slimy and almost unmanageable.

The sky was full of rain again but they knew now that even if it did not rain in the Fens the danger was coming from the water which fell many miles away in the Midlands and in Bedfordshire, and that the swollen rivers were still rushing down to the plain while the wind which fretted these floods into the banks, made a menace which it was very hard to fight.

So they worked on with them men, laughing and joking with them, until a shout and disturbance about fifty yards away broke the rhythm of their toil. They looked round to see that the water had found a weakness in the wall and was gushing through the cracks between the bags like a fountain. There was another similar leak nearer to them on their other side, and now the gangs plastered these leaks with clay without waiting to bag it.

Reader's voice: Have you by any chance written something about Saville's books recently?

Liberal England replies: Funny you should ask. You can read my Malcolm Saville and the children’s holiday adventure over on Lion & Unicorn.

Monday, November 09, 2026

The Joy of Six 1604

Lucy Siegle is not impressed by the Guardian's attempt to play down its long and close involvement with Russell Brand: "My favourite evidence suggesting a deeper relationship ... is the stuff on its own website including photographic evidence of young Russell perched next to former editor Alan Rushbridger at Guardian conference. This is framed as one of Alan Rushbridger’s highlights on leaving in 2015."

"As I started to step outside of the MAGA media bubble, I started to gradually realise that so much of what I believed turned out to be false. I spent a lot of nights in solitude with my thoughts going through this year-long personally tumultuous time, where I had to examine ... what had been sincerely held beliefs that were false." Rich Logis talks to Byline Times about the organisation he has created to help others exit from the extremist group.

"When you open Speed Grader to confront another bland but competent assignment, suspiciously devoid of grammatical or spelling errors, your heart sinks. You know that, in all probability, the document you're reading was composed not by your student (whose contribution likely extended no further than dropping the essay question into Claude’s interface and adding 'make it sound human'), but by a legion of absent (and, quite probably, deceased) authors, whose forgotten texts enabled an algorithm to stitch together an essay that is at least passable and often reasonably good." Jeff Sparrow on what AI is doing to universities.

Mira Ptacin speaks up for feral children: "These kids already spend most of their weekdays indoors, where bells regulate their movements and adults regulate their voices. The ferry ride is one of the few unsupervised stretches left in their day: 20 minutes on the ocean suspended between island and mainland when they can be loud, loose, ridiculous and wholly themselves."

Peter Asher looks back on his 60 years in the music business.

"It’s a magnificent sweep, hardly noticed by most passengers as they alight from their train – minding the gap between the train and the platform edge, of course – and hurry to the exit and whatever has brought them to York in the first place." English Buildings celebrates the curved trainshed at York station.

GUEST POST Joe Meek and an old case of misattribution

Everyone makes mistakes, says Matthew Lawrenson. Most are discovered fairly quickly and put right. But sometimes, they drag on for years and years with nobody bothering to correct them, despite all the evidence being available to do so.

Glenda Collins was a 1960s female singer with an ill-starred career. A contemporary of fellow London Jewish vocalist Helen Shapiro (though her recording career started a few months earlier), she released three singles on Decca in 1960-61 which flopped. Released from her contract, she had to find alternative arrangements.

Luckily, independent producer Joe Meek was on the lookout for new talent and signed her up in 1963. Every few months, Glenda would traipse up to Meek's studio on the Holloway Road in Islington to record a new track. Joe would work his famous magic and sell the master to a big label. When her new record was released, Glenda would be given a new haircut and a new outfit and be sent out on a promo tour. Sadly, all eight singles she made with Meek also flopped.

While the likes of HMV and Pye were happy to release Joe Meek's productions – Joe having paid for the recording and mastering himself – they concentrated their promotional efforts on their in-house artists and the likes of Glenda Collins got what was left.

As for why Glenda stayed with Meek for so long, well, apparently her father/manager was very protective. And whatever has been said about Joe’s proclivities, your attractive young daughter was always going to be safe with him. Glenda’s recording career died with Joe, on that infamous day in February 1967 when Meek shot his landlady and then himself.

All this is well-documented music history, so what’s the problem here? Well, Glenda’s penultimate single on HMV was Johnny Loves Me, a cover of the Shelley Fabares hit written by Barry Mann and Cynthia Weil in 1962. Or was it? The credits on the label said it was.

That’s not the song Glenda recorded, so what gives? What we seem to have here is an example of record company laziness and inattention. As the Meek-made single wasn’t produced in-house, whomever did the admin at HMV in 1965 simply assumed it was Fabares's hit (no. 21 in the USA Cashbox charts). And on every compilation since, Johnny Loves Me by Glenda Collins has been credited to Mann/Weil. 

So, who really did the original version? Here it is.

This was released in 1963 in Sweden by Suzie, a Dutch/Swedish singer produced by songwriter John L. Finneran, an American who’d moved to Scandinavia after his USA music career faltered. And, as you can hear, despite Joe Meek’s much-vaunted innovation, he pretty much copied it for Glenda’s track. 

How he got hold of a song that was probably never released in the UK is not known, but my guess is that another of his artists, Michael Cox (who was huge in Sweden), brought a copy back after touring there with his song Stand Up.

John L. Finneran died in 1973. So if he ever found out his songwriting royalties were being diverted to Mann and Weil, there's not much he could have done about it after that. The small amount of money generated by Glenda’s track would have been dwarfed in 1965 by other, more successful Mann/Weil songs such as, say, You’ve Lost That Loving Feeling.

Me, I discovered this by accident a few weeks ago. I contacted the Joe Meek Society about it on the off-chance and they hadn’t realised either. Discogs and 45cat have been contacted and corrections made, and the Performing Rights Society will be informed and all future royalties diverted to the proper channels. 

We'll just have to wait to see if Barry Mann himself gets a letter delivered to his home in Los Angeles informing him that Glenda won’t be making him any more money in the future.

Matthew Lawrenson has been an amateur writer for over 30 years, in the sense that though he has produced hundreds of thousands of words, he has never been paid for a single one.

Sunday, November 08, 2026

Abdul El-Sayed captained the University of Oxford lacrosse team

Embed from Getty Images

Lovers of trivia will know that Kris Kristofferson won a boxing Blue for Oxford, but our Trivia Desk has news of another American Rhodes Scholar who represented the university at sport.

It comes from England Lacrosse:

Former University of Oxford Lacrosse Club defender and men’s captain Abdul El-Sayed has become the first Muslim-American, first Egyptian-American, and surely first Oxford Men’s Lacrosse Club alumni elected to the United States Senate after victory in the mid-term elections on Tuesday.

 This is definitely our Trivial Fact of the Day.

It's Wednesday so it must be Much Wenlock

Tuesday was Ellesmere. But this is Wednesday, so it must be Much Wenlock.

I spent much of my time there enjoying the Abbey grounds, but here are some photos I took in the town. 

The half-timbered house above is the one where wartime evacuees are supposed to have come down to breakfast on their first morning and demanded to know who the children in strange clothes they'd been playing with were.

Madra Salach: Ribbon Factory

Madra Salach – Dirty Dog in English – are a contemporary Irish folk band and Ribbon Factory, released as a single last month, will be on their debut album when it comes out in January.

The Guardian says they bring 

a feral, snarling energy to the country’s latest folk revival. Their sound builds ably on some of the architects of that resurgence – the eerie shruti box droning and carefully layered instrumentation of Lankum, the shimmering wails of Lisa O’Neill. 
Add a hint of Liam Gallagher to the mix – frontman Paul Banks’s voice has an astonishing force and clarity, and he affects a tempestuous, attack-and-withdraw relationship with the microphone – and you’ve got a very exciting package indeed.

A stereotypical Irish reader adds: Yer da's been listening to Radio 6 Music again.