Tuesday, June 06, 2023

Poverty isn't a lack of character: it's a lack of cash


Rutger Bregman begins his TED talk like this:
I'd like to start with a simple question: Why do the poor make so many poor decisions? I know it's a harsh question, but take a look at the data. The poor borrow more, save less, smoke more, exercise less, drink more and eat less healthfully. Why? 
Well, the standard explanation was once summed up by the British Prime Minister, Margaret Thatcher. And she called poverty "a personality defect." 
[Laughter] 
A lack of character, basically.
I'm suspicious of quotations that are so convenient for the speakers' argument, but Thatch really did say this. It was in a 1978 interview with the Catholic Herald.

But then large parts of the Labour Party are more interested in reforming the working class than liberating it too.

As I said of Blair's new government in a letter to the Guardian in 1997 (which I later found quoted in a book I had bought):
Labour is effectively recasting unemployment as a form of individual delinquency.
And Labour is still at it. Today Darren Rodwell, who is apparently a rising star of the party, was threatening to evict families from council accommodation if their children don't inform on people who commit knife crime.

So it's important that Liberals continue to discuss utopian ideas like basic income and a reduced working week. Most will probably prove to be unworkable, but where there is no vision the people perish.

2 comments:

nigel hunter said...

UBI is fine but surely there has to be a cut off point for psyment.For sure millionaires will not need the money! Finland noted it helped the mental well being of people so it could help reduce NHS costs in this area.

Phil Beesley said...

I remember being in a Victorian bath house in New Zealand when a Brit asked the guide whether being over weight was a genetic factor for indigenous people. The guide blustered, and being British I didn't blurt out that poor people may be fat because they can only afford less healthy food.