Liberal Democrat Blog of the Year 2014
"Well written, funny and wistful" - Paul Linford; "He is indeed the Lib Dem blogfather" - Stephen Tall
"Jonathan Calder holds his end up well in the competitive world of the blogosphere" - New Statesman
"A prominent Liberal Democrat blogger" - BBC Radio 4 Today; "One of my favourite blogs" - Stumbling
and Mumbling; "Charming and younger than I expected" - Wartime Housewife
Sunday, February 04, 2018
Bromlow Callow close up
One of the landmarks of the Shropshire hills is Bromlow Callow. The trees that crest this hill can be seen for miles, though this photograph shows them close up.
Bromlow Callow stands to the west of the Stiperstones - close to the pub where Eric Clapton and Ronnie Lane once played.
Lib Dems slip back in Cornish local by-election
![]() |
| Photo of Falmouth © Colin Babb |
This was a reminder of what hard work targeted on a compact urban ward can achieve against a party that has been in power too long – in Sunderland that was the Labour Party.
It is good that the Lib Dems can still record such victories and may well be an omen of further gains in Sunderland in May.
This result also reminds us that it is not so long since we ran Newcastle upon Tyne and had serious ambitions of gaining Labour seats in the North East.
What it does not do is show that Sunderland has changed its mind on the European Union or show that we are poised to sweep to power with similar swings across the country,
On the same night there was another local by-election in Falmouth, where Labour held the seat made vacant by the death of the town’s former MP Candy Atherton.
Even though the Conservative candidate had to apologise during the campaign Nazi-themed Facebook posts he had made, the Liberal Democrat vote slipped back from 18.9 per cent to 17.2 per cent.
A former MP will probably have looked after the ward and her death might well have led to a significant sympathy vote for Labour, but this is still disappointing.
After all, the Liberal Democrats held the old Falmouth and Camborne constituency between 2005 and 2010.
Last year we came third in the new Falmouth and Redruth with six per cent of the vote. If there had been a Ukip candidate we would probably have come fourth.
Yet we have fallen back on our result in the election that took place in the same ward a month before the general election.
I love to see the Lib Dems gaining seats in local by-elections and tweet the results as eagerly as anyone.
But, as I have blogged before, we must beware of confirmation bias – our tendency to notice evidence that supports our view (say, that there is a Lib Dem revival taking place) and pass rapidly over evidence that does not.
I suspect this bias explains why we Lib Dems were disappointed by last year’s general election result and even more why we were shocked when we lost seats in the local elections the month before.
This week a national opinion poll showed the Lib Dems on 6 per cent. That sounds a little low, but if it had been 7 per cent it would have been more or less in line with other recent polls.
And that means the party is still deep in the doldrums. Yes, there are wards and constituencies where we are doing much better than 6 or 7 per cent, but those areas will have been polled like any others.
That means there must be plenty of areas where we are doing significantly worse than 6 or 7 per cent.
Local by-elections often tell us this, but those are not the results we retweet to each other.
I once tweeted to point out that we had scored less than 1 per cent in one contest. I immediately had someone giving me reasons why this was nothing to worry about.
I take no pleasure in this situation and can suggest no easy recipe for improving the party’s fortunes.

But it is best to face the truth, otherwise we shall continue to be disappointed by every round of national elections.
Lord Bonkers' Diary: Pelted with sharpened carrots
Knowing what a wise old bird Lord Bonkers is, I would not wager much against Boris Johnson's career ending just as he foretells.
Pelted with sharpened carrots
There is nothing the people of London enjoy more than a good Cabinet reshuffle. From early morning the crowds gather to see the fun: flower girls, costermongers (whatever they are) and scruffy urchins all assemble at the gates of Downing Street (in my young day you could walk into Number 10 and demand pot of tea, but times change and not for the better) to observe the comings and goings.
If a particularly juicy reshuffle is expected then temporary grandstands may be erected and, depending on the season, sellers of ice cream or hot roast chestnuts do a roaring trade.
I joined the throng this morning. How we laughed when we heard Grayling had been made Chairman of the Conservative Party! Then we laughed because it was announced when he had not been. The strange Gavin Williamson was pelted with sharpened carrots and Jeremy Hunt was roundly booed.
I did not spot Boris Johnson today, but I remain convinced that his career will end with his being running down Whitehall in polka-dot boxer shorts pursued by an angry mob.
Lord Bonkers was Liberal MP for Rutland South West, 1906-10.
Pelted with sharpened carrots
There is nothing the people of London enjoy more than a good Cabinet reshuffle. From early morning the crowds gather to see the fun: flower girls, costermongers (whatever they are) and scruffy urchins all assemble at the gates of Downing Street (in my young day you could walk into Number 10 and demand pot of tea, but times change and not for the better) to observe the comings and goings.
If a particularly juicy reshuffle is expected then temporary grandstands may be erected and, depending on the season, sellers of ice cream or hot roast chestnuts do a roaring trade.
I joined the throng this morning. How we laughed when we heard Grayling had been made Chairman of the Conservative Party! Then we laughed because it was announced when he had not been. The strange Gavin Williamson was pelted with sharpened carrots and Jeremy Hunt was roundly booed.
I did not spot Boris Johnson today, but I remain convinced that his career will end with his being running down Whitehall in polka-dot boxer shorts pursued by an angry mob.
Lord Bonkers was Liberal MP for Rutland South West, 1906-10.
Previously in Lord Bonkers' Diary
London O'Connor: Nobody Hangs Out Anymore
This turned up on Radio 3's Late Junction the other night and sounded good. It starts off like a lost Tim Booth song.
London O'Connor was profiled in the Guardian a couple of years ago:
O’Connor is a wanderer. Originally from San Marcos, California, he has spent the past two years hopping around, crashing with friends here and there, making a quick trip to Europe last year to play some shows, but mostly embracing a life of rootlessness. "Couch life is a little awkward sometimes," he tells me, thinking out loud about how he never gets to be alone. We talk and walk aimlessly in circles around the park, past the park’s usual characters who play chess, shoot the shit on benches, skateboard on the basketball court.
"I wear the same thing every day because it simplifies life for me," he says. "It lets me just focus on how I feel on the inside. When I started doing it, part me was frustrated with this feeling that you’re supposed to change, or give up on your dreams. So I’m just not changing."As to the burden of this song:
"Growing up on the internet gave so many of us a voice that we wouldn’t really have otherwise," he says. “But recently, it makes me more and more uncomfortable. Because it feels like on social, some of the values are the opposite of what I value and care about as an artist.
"As an artist, all I care about is figuring out what’s true to me, and saying that. Regardless of how it’s going to be received. So much of Twitter is people saying things that they don’t feel, based on how often it’s going to get favorited or retweeted. It just gets in the way."
Saturday, February 03, 2018
Six of the Best 765
Replying to the Michael Meadowcroft article included in the last of these round ups, Paul Holmes says a good targeting strategy is essential for the Liberal Democrats.
"Mainstream society has laid down with dogs and we have now got up with fleas." Matthew Collins says we have become comfortable with hate.
Hadley Freeman asks why actors are suddenly lining up to condemn Woody Allen: "I get why people feel icky about Allen. Some of us were rolling our eyes at Manhattan, his film about a man’s relationship with a schoolgirl, before the leading lights of #MeToo were born. But this is not a case that should be tried by public opinion."
Torie Bosch is fascinated by the "List of people who disappeared mysteriously" page on Wikipedia.
"The love Crook has for these characters shines through, and part of the joy of the show is in how likeable they are. Perhaps that’s why it’s accumulated such a strikingly devoted audience over the last couple of years." Anna Leszkiewicz analyses the appeal of Detectorists.
Tim Holyoake has some great pictures of the Derwent dams taken during a drought in 1959.
"Mainstream society has laid down with dogs and we have now got up with fleas." Matthew Collins says we have become comfortable with hate.
Hadley Freeman asks why actors are suddenly lining up to condemn Woody Allen: "I get why people feel icky about Allen. Some of us were rolling our eyes at Manhattan, his film about a man’s relationship with a schoolgirl, before the leading lights of #MeToo were born. But this is not a case that should be tried by public opinion."
Torie Bosch is fascinated by the "List of people who disappeared mysteriously" page on Wikipedia.
"The love Crook has for these characters shines through, and part of the joy of the show is in how likeable they are. Perhaps that’s why it’s accumulated such a strikingly devoted audience over the last couple of years." Anna Leszkiewicz analyses the appeal of Detectorists.
Tim Holyoake has some great pictures of the Derwent dams taken during a drought in 1959.
Lord Bonkers' Diary: Defying the Sprout Police
You may recall that, just before Christmas, Leicestershire County Council announced that a single portion of sprouts consisted of six - no more, no less.
The old boy was having none of it.
Defying the Sprout Police
One of the great occasions of the year here on the Bonkers Hall Estate is Christmas Eve. Dressed in a red suit, I visit the cottages of my tenants and hand over hampers of fine things to eat and drink: a goose from the Home Farm; pies and puddings from the kitchens at the Hall; a bottle of Meadowcroft’s parsnip wine (which would make anyone merry).
I am always accompanied by a flock of Well-Behaved Orphans dressed as elves (adds to the festive effect, don’t you think?), but this year I took the precaution of adding a brace of gamekeepers armed with orchard doughties to the company.
Because one of the traditions of these hampers is that every tenant receives precisely seven Brussels sprouts. Yet a few days before Christmas there went out a decree from the Conservative-run Leicestershire County Council’s Sprout Compliance Unit saying no one should eat more than six of the things. I wasn’t having that – hence the extra muscle on hand on Christmas Eve.
Perhaps because we had also doubled the guard on the border, I am able to report that Leicestershire’s hated Sprout Police made no attempt to enter Rutland during the festive season, so a merry Christmas was enjoyed by all.
The old boy was having none of it.
Defying the Sprout Police
One of the great occasions of the year here on the Bonkers Hall Estate is Christmas Eve. Dressed in a red suit, I visit the cottages of my tenants and hand over hampers of fine things to eat and drink: a goose from the Home Farm; pies and puddings from the kitchens at the Hall; a bottle of Meadowcroft’s parsnip wine (which would make anyone merry).
I am always accompanied by a flock of Well-Behaved Orphans dressed as elves (adds to the festive effect, don’t you think?), but this year I took the precaution of adding a brace of gamekeepers armed with orchard doughties to the company.
Because one of the traditions of these hampers is that every tenant receives precisely seven Brussels sprouts. Yet a few days before Christmas there went out a decree from the Conservative-run Leicestershire County Council’s Sprout Compliance Unit saying no one should eat more than six of the things. I wasn’t having that – hence the extra muscle on hand on Christmas Eve.
Perhaps because we had also doubled the guard on the border, I am able to report that Leicestershire’s hated Sprout Police made no attempt to enter Rutland during the festive season, so a merry Christmas was enjoyed by all.
Lord Bonkers was Liberal MP for Rutland South West, 1906-10.
Previously in Lord Bonkers' Diary
Liberator has the inside track on the Lib Dems
Each issue of Liberator carries a Radical Bulletin section, which gives the inside news on the Liberal Democrats.
Radical Bulletin in the new issue of Liberator includes stories on:
- tensions between the PPC, the local party and the regional party in Lewes
- the travails of Ethnic Minority Liberal Democrsts
- the regional party official who is a member of another group on an authority run by the Lib Dems
The conclusion is clear. If you want to know what is going on in the party you should subscribe to Liberator.
Friday, February 02, 2018
St Pancras to New Holland Pier in 1976
Footage from a rail tour in August 1976. On the way up we catches glimpses of Leicester station and a long-vanished signal box and of class 76 locomotives on the Woodhead route.
New Holland Pier was where the ferry to Hull left from the Lincolnshire shore of the Humber.
The service ended when the bridge opened in 1981 and New Holland Pier station (which I visited a couple of years after this video was shot) closed too. Here the paddle steamer Lincoln Castle takes you down the coast to Grimsby.
Coming back the train passes through the lost station of Lincoln St Marks.
Lord Bonkers' Diary: Mooning practice on the village green
The new issue of Liberator is on its way to subscribers, so it is time to spend a few days at Bonkers Hall.
I am sure Lord Bonkers would suggest you subscribe to Liberator yourself.
Mooning practice on the village green
It has been a hard winter in Rutland, but we have not allowed that to interfere with our preparations for the visit of President Trump. To a man and, indeed, a woman, we are determined to give him a fitting reception. Mooning practice has taken place on the village green every Monday and Thursday since Michaelmas and the charabancs to London have long been booked.
So great has been the enthusiasm for marking his visit hereabouts that I am exploring the possibility of running a special train from Bonkers Halt, via the rather rusty junction north of Market Harborough, to St Pancras, but the absurd franchising system on the railways does not encourage this sort of individual enterprise.
Lord Bonkers was Liberal MP for Rutland South West, 1906-10.
I am sure Lord Bonkers would suggest you subscribe to Liberator yourself.
Mooning practice on the village green
It has been a hard winter in Rutland, but we have not allowed that to interfere with our preparations for the visit of President Trump. To a man and, indeed, a woman, we are determined to give him a fitting reception. Mooning practice has taken place on the village green every Monday and Thursday since Michaelmas and the charabancs to London have long been booked.
So great has been the enthusiasm for marking his visit hereabouts that I am exploring the possibility of running a special train from Bonkers Halt, via the rather rusty junction north of Market Harborough, to St Pancras, but the absurd franchising system on the railways does not encourage this sort of individual enterprise.
Lord Bonkers was Liberal MP for Rutland South West, 1906-10.
Northamptonshire County Council brings in emergency spending controls
Alarming news from the Conservative-run Northamptonshire County Council this evening:
A cash-strapped local authority has imposed emergency spending controls as it faces "severe financial challenges".
The section 114 notice bans all new expenditure at Northamptonshire County Council, with the exception of statutory services for protecting vulnerable people.
Last month the government said an inspector would look into allegations of financial failings at the authority.
The notice is to be discussed at the full council meeting on 22 February.It's been clear for some time that Northamptonshire has serious problems.
At the start of the year Sajid Javid, the secretary of state for housing, communities and local government, announced a government inspector is to look into the authority's finances.
And last week the council announced plans to sell and lease back its new headquarters.
An old post by Alison Scott on Public Finance explains what a section 114 notice involves - a 'CFO' is a chief financial officer:
The ultimate recourse of the CFO remains the section 114 powers of the Local Government Finance Act 1988. These are not to be taken lightly and should be used very carefully and only after great consideration.
Section 114 requires the CFO, in consultation with the council’s monitoring officer, to report to all the authority’s members if (in broad terms) there is, or is likely to be, an unbalanced budget.
This would include situations where reserves have become seriously depleted and it is forecast that the authority will not have the resources to meet its expenditure in a particular financial year.
The issue of a section 114 notice has serious operational implications. Indeed, the authority’s full council must meet within 21 days to consider the notice. During that period, the authority is prohibited from entering into new agreements involving spending.Councils are the only public bodies required by law to set a balanced budget every year.
Thursday, February 01, 2018
All of Desborough's Tory town councillors have resigned
From BBC News:
All Conservative members of a town council have resigned after "bullying, abuse and harassment" of the former chairman and her family.
Jane Pearce stood down from Desborough Town Council in Northamptonshire two weeks ago amid claims of abuse against her family from members of the public.
It began after a 400% increase in council tax in 2016, when the annual levy rose from £19.10 to £96.98.
Now all 10 Tory councillors have resigned from the 12-person council.As I wrote at the time of the increase, "If ever a town gave the visitor the impression that it needs some money spent on it, that town is Desborough".
Llewelyn ap Iorwerth in Lancaster Square, Conwy
From the Welcome to Conwy site:
Lancaster Square is the town square in the centre of Conwy. It hosts several festivals and events each and every year. In 2013 it held the start of the famous Wales Rally GB.
In the centre of Lancaster Square is a statue of Llewelyn ap Iorwerth (or Llewelyn the Great) who stands proudly above a fountain painted in his heritage colours.
The writing that is in scripted on the fountain says that Llewelyn founded Aberconwy Abbey in 1186, some even say that Llewellyn founded the town himself.
The bronze statue was created by a man named E.O Griffith in 1898 and was commemorated to introduce the towns water supply.
Llewelyn was said to be born in Dolwyddelan Castle in 1173 and raised in Powys. By the age of 10, Llewelyn had begun his military career and in 1201 he had successfully conquered Gwynedd.
In 1209, Llewelyn became the first Welsh leader to join an English King on a campaign outside Wales, they would join together and try to defeat William I of Scotland.I took this photograph of the statue on holiday in 2010.
Oxford University Conservative Association hired Black Cab Rapist as a stripper for a social event
An extraordinary story from Cherwell, the Oxford student newspaper:
The Cherwell website goes on to say that following the eventL
h/t Otto English.
The Oxford University Conservative Association (OUCA) once hired the ‘Black cab rapist’ then working as a stripper, for an infamous cabaret social.
John Worboys, then know as ‘Terry the Minder’, performed a striptease for Tory members, alongside a female stripper named “the exotic Vashanti”
The event at Hertford College was attended by a young Sally Bercow (then Illman), wife of Commons Speaker John Bercow. She was blindfolded on stage before Worboys suggestively placed a banana in her hand.
According to a report at the time, prominent Tory backbencher Jacob Rees Mogg “heartily approved of [the event].By accident or design, it is impossible to read the website's image of the 1989 Cherwell front page where the story was first reported.
The Cherwell website goes on to say that following the eventL
the Senior Proctor of the University refused to recognise OUCA as an official society, banning the Association from using the ‘Oxford University’ title in its name. The Association were also prohibited from holding events at Hertford. The ban apparently remains in place today.This story has also made The Sun, which has lots about Sally Bercow but does not mention Rees-Mogg.
h/t Otto English.
Wednesday, January 31, 2018
See Rutland in 1957
Click on the image above to view this film on the British Film Institute site.
There's no commentary, but you will see Uppingham and Oakham, Stoke Dry church, the sculptures at Exton (which was more than I could when I went there) and the turf maze at Wing.
New Ware wine bar 'would lead to more graveyard sex', residents warn
The Hertfordshire Mercury provides our Headline of the Day.
New light on the suspension of two Lib Dem members of City of York Council's executive?
The City of York Council is run by a Conservative and Liberal Democrat coalition.
This week the leader of the council, David Carr, was ousted as leader of the Conservative Group.
He has been succeeded as group leader by Ian Gillies, though he is not yet the leader of the council as it is subject to a vote at full council.
York's daily paper The Press says Ian Gillies will:
review the case of two Lib Dem councillors who were suspended from City of York Council's executive by David Carr.
Cllr Ian Gillies, the new Conservative leader who is set to become council leader next month, was responding to a question from The Press about the futures of Cllrs Keith Aspden and Nigel Ayre following the ousting of Cllr Carr as Tory leader.This affair has always been a little mysterious, as the allegations against the two Lib Dem councillors have never been made public.
The Press does say North Yorkshire Police have announced they will not be investigating them.Perhaps more light will now be shed on this murky affair?
Tuesday, January 30, 2018
The Three Tuns Brewery, Bishop's Castle, in 1977
This short news report shows them and the town as they were in 1977.
Six of the Best 764
"By definition, once we have no campaigning in a majority of seats our organisation atrophies and we lose the deliverers, canvassers and all the local workers in those seats. Then, at the following election, the number of workers available to go to target seats dwindles away and the strategy doesn’t even work for target seats." Michael Meadowcroft argues that targeting has mortally wounded the Liberal Democrats.
Frances Coppola explains how Carillion used a British government scheme to rip off its suppliers.
A lost opportunity? Rail Magazine on the closed March to Spalding line, which I travelled on as a student.
"The song has been endlessly analysed; it’s intentionally ambiguous and the meanings are still up for debate. But let’s take a stab at it line by line." Yeoman Lowbrow has another look at Don McLean's American Pie.
James Dilley, an experimental archaeologist and specialist in European prehistory, has been to see Early Man - Aardman’s latest animated adventure
"Moondial taps into that area of the brain which operates purely on instinct and won't rest until every square inch of your body is covered in goosebumps." Curious British Telly celebrates the 1988 children's series.
Frances Coppola explains how Carillion used a British government scheme to rip off its suppliers.
A lost opportunity? Rail Magazine on the closed March to Spalding line, which I travelled on as a student.
"The song has been endlessly analysed; it’s intentionally ambiguous and the meanings are still up for debate. But let’s take a stab at it line by line." Yeoman Lowbrow has another look at Don McLean's American Pie.
James Dilley, an experimental archaeologist and specialist in European prehistory, has been to see Early Man - Aardman’s latest animated adventure
"Moondial taps into that area of the brain which operates purely on instinct and won't rest until every square inch of your body is covered in goosebumps." Curious British Telly celebrates the 1988 children's series.
Monday, January 29, 2018
"I think we will stay": Vince Cable on Brexit
“It’s only a matter of time before we come back in Montgomeryshire. It was a Lib Dem stronghold – we will be back.”That's what Vince Cable told a meeting at Welshpool Town Hall on Saturday.
The Shropshire Star has a video of him speaking at the event and quotes his views on Brexit:
“The split between leave and remain hasn’t changed very much. It’s moved a little bit towards people who think leaving is a bad idea, but it’s not shifted a great deal.
"If they were to set for another vote, this time on the facts, it will be for about Christmas time.
"I think once people are clearer about what Brexit means, a lot of the negatives that were not really brought out in the last campaign, I think we will stay."I knew having a photo of Welshpool Town Hall would come in useful one day.
Sunday, January 28, 2018
The railway from Hastings to Ashford: Part 2
The waiting is over. On Thursday evening I posted part 1 of a video about the Hastings to Ashford line.
Here is the second and final part.
Another memory from that holiday at Winchelsea Beach in 1967.
My parents told me that I should not pick up any metal object I found on the beach.
That was because it was only 22 years after the end of the Second World War when the beach would have been mined.
And here I am well into the 21st century.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)








