Monday, November 16, 2026

Labour and the NEETs: Nothing has changed in 30 years

Embed from Getty Images

In a letter to the Guardian on 15 September 1997, Jonathan Calder wrote: "Labour is effectively recasting unemployment as a form of individual delinquency."

That letter can no longer be found on the Guardian website, but its central point is preserved for ever in this quotation from The Age of Insecurity by Larry Elliott and Dan Atkinson (published in 1998).

What is depressing is that nothing has changed in the three decades since I wrote that letter. The current debate over NEETs is predicated on the belief that is only young people stirred themselves they would find jobs. Hence the emphasis on the question of whether welfare benefits are too generous.

One exception to this approach can be found in an article from today's Guardian by Richard Partington:

Unemployment among the under-25s has risen at the fastest rate since the 2008 financial crisis to reach its highest level relative to the total for all ages since the early 1990s. Young people now make up about 40 per cent of all unemployment.

All of this compounds a drop in entry-level jobs over the past two decades. The Saturday job died long ago, while to make matters worse, those positions at the start of the career ladder are most at risk of automation or replacement by AI.

Perhaps unsurprisingly, the places in Britain with the fewest job vacancies have the highest Neet rates. Highlighting stark regional divisions, young jobseekers in Rotherham face a sixfold gap in opportunity relative to their peers in the Cotswolds.

The preferred fixes called for by employers are tax cuts, looser regulations, and holding back rises in the youth minimum wage. But while policy costs are unquestionably a factor to consider, and the state could do more to help young people get ready for work, the problems go much deeper.

Labour and Liberal politicians have lost any notion that it is possible for them to intervene beneficently at a macroeconomic level. All that remain are interventions to make the young keener to work or more fitted to the workplace – and this at a time when we are told we should be celebrating the success of English schools at least in the PISA tables.

It's enough to make you nostalgia for the Thatcher government, which paid an enterprise allowance to young people who wanted to start their own business. This helped many musicians and other artists with very unThatcherite politics to pursue their dreams.

No comments:

Post a Comment